My Freemasonry | Freemason Information and Discussion Forum

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Representing the Craft

Do you think representing the craft as if it were a college frat has a negative or positive impact?


  • Total voters
    29

lilhut3579

Registered User
So I mean the regalia mostly and there has been a hand sign. i assume its making a square but basically making a square with the index finger and thumb.
 

Ripcord22A

Site Benefactor
So I mean the regalia mostly and there has been a hand sign. i assume its making a square but basically making a square with the index finger and thumb.

Our regalia is nothing like that of a GREEK frat. they wear hoodies and what not with their letters on em. As for hand signs of its not the DG and PS of a degree, the GHSD or the grips then it is not masonic
 

MRichard

Mark A. Ri'chard
Premium Member
b78eebf70221df8edb6fb68b3dc216ab.jpg


There are some similarities between PHA and the Divine 9 fraternities. Most of the Divine 9 fraternities founders were PHA at some point in time. They both use lines to initiate candidates (well not sure if all PHA do). They are similarities in the ritual as well. Their rituals used ours as a blueprint or pattern. I belong to a Divine 9 fraternity. Divine 9 fraternities are historically Black ones in case you were wondering. I am not saying that PHA is like a college frat, I am saying there are similarities.
 

acjohnson53

Registered User
Although I did not pledge while in college because I had other things on my mind, there is no similarity of college frat and the Masonic Faith, as said the Masonic Brother are held accountable for their action a nd up hold the true meaning of the Craft...
 

MRichard

Mark A. Ri'chard
Premium Member
Although I did not pledge while in college because I had other things on my mind, there is no similarity of college frat and the Masonic Faith, as said the Masonic Brother are held accountable for their action a nd up hold the true meaning of the Craft...

I respectively disagree. There are definitely some similarities. But they are totally different organizations. PHA masonry definitely had a profound influence on the Divine 9 fraternities.
 

Dontrell Stroman

Premium Member
If paraphernalia is what we are talking about in terms of representing the organization then it isn't a big deal in my eyes. I agree that alot of the older brothers have a lot of critique when it comes to younger brothers wearing paraphernalia. I think it becomes a problem if said brother(s) decide he or they want to throw a college party. The difference is, those fraternities are social groups whereas Masonry is not a social group but every now and then you come across ones who treat it as such and that is where the issue comes in. Am I right, @Travelling Man91?
Agreed.
 

The Traveling Man

Registered User
Lately I've been seeing an increase in younger Masons representing the fraternity in a college fraternity like manner. Mainly PHA Masons. I wonder why? Not saying its a bad thing. I myself had a pretty "shiny" jacket made. Its the older brothers who seem to have more a problem with it. I want to know thoughts on this from not only PH brothers but Mainstream brothers as well.

p.s.

I'm 24 any brother out there younger than me?

I don't think jackets, hats, etc are symbolic of a college frat. It's no different than someone in the union to wear a union shirt or jacket, or an employee to wear something bearing the name or logo of his job. I don't have a jacket yet, but I have Masonic shirts, earrings, rings, bracelets, pins and car decals. I'm proud to be a Mason so I show it. But it isn't so much for the public to see as it is for other Brothers to notice it. Where I'm at I see it more with the older members. They have the jackets, the license plates, multiple pins, etc. I see it more with Brothers from my Grand Lodge than with the PHA Brothers, but I suspect it's probably about even. I'm 33 and the members in my Lodge that are younger than me I haven't seen with Any of those items yet.
 
Last edited:

Glen Cook

G A Cook
Site Benefactor
Although I did not pledge while in college because I had other things on my mind, there is no similarity of college frat and the Masonic Faith, as said the Masonic Brother are held accountable for their action a nd up hold the true meaning of the Craft...
Umm, "Masonic Faith"?
 

Dontrell Stroman

Premium Member
I will say that some lodges near college universities govern themselves in a way that a college fraternity does. They pledge, party, "Step" and design their jackets in a way college frats do. I would not venture out to say this is a PHA thing. I know many clandestine AF&AM have lodges set up all over the big cities in TN. A lot of times brothers see guys acting and dressing this way, and automatically assume it's a PHA thing. I don't think it's a unrealistic assumption due to the fact how would you know PHA from clandestine mason without asking or seeing a charter. They use the same symbols as all regular masons.
 

Dontrell Stroman

Premium Member
Without a doubt I believe it's younger masons. In my own experiences, I've yet to see a older mason acting that way. That's not to say their aren't some out here.
 

MRichard

Mark A. Ri'chard
Premium Member
Without a doubt I believe it's younger masons. In my own experiences, I've yet to see a older mason acting that way. That's not to say their aren't some out here.

There are many PHA Shriners videos on youtube doing the camel walk. I assume you have to be a PHA mason to be a PHA Shriner. Kinda like stepping.
 

Dontrell Stroman

Premium Member
I don't know much about the Shriner's due to the fact that I am not one, but I am aware that PHA Shriner's do the "Camel walk". My objection is, Shriner's and Freemasons are two different and separate organizations. That might be the custom and tradition for PHA Shriner's to do the camel walk, but it's not for PHA freemasonry.

Sent from my 831C using My Freemasonry Pro mobile app
 

MRichard

Mark A. Ri'chard
Premium Member
I don't know much about the Shriner's due to the fact that I am not one, but I am aware that PHA Shriner's do the "Camel walk". My objection is, Shriner's and Freemasons are two different and separate organizations. That might be the custom and tradition for PHA Shriner's to do the camel walk, but it's not for PHA freemasonry.

Sent from my 831C using My Freemasonry Pro mobile app

So those are not PHA masons? I never said it was the custom. You said you never saw older brothers act that way. There were definitely some older brothers in that video.
 
Last edited:

Dontrell Stroman

Premium Member
Yes they are masons, but they are not acting under freemasonry when it comes to dancing. They are doing something their appendent body come up with. I still haven't seen older freemasons, meaning just blue Lodge brothers dancing and acting like a College frat. But it's not a Masonic offense to dance anyways. I saw Shriner's doing a dance for their organization, but I've yet to see PHA masons representing the blue lodge dance in that kind of way.

Sent from my 831C using My Freemasonry Pro mobile app
 
Top