My Freemasonry | Freemason Information and Discussion Forum

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Want to research the 5 points of fellowship and looking for good source material.

Symthrell

Registered User
A discussion has come up about the meaning behind some of the 5 points of fellowship. I want to research the deeper meanings and see if I can help both sides of the debate at my lodge understand the true meaning. I think both sides have solid merit but both seem to be missing something, what I am not quite sure of yet.

Any ideas on where to start looking would be greatly appreciated.
 

HoldenMonty

Registered User
That is a tough question to answer on a public forum. There is some on it in my Third Degree lessons. And even though I was able to find it in a presentation on my GL's website I'm just going to say what it initially stands for. The first point is companionship, the second point symbolizes fellowship with our creator, the third point is further evidence of fellowship, the fourth point indicates our backs must be strong enough and willing to support each other's burdens. The fifth point is meant to teach us that we should be ever ready to whisper good counsel in the ear of a Brother.
 

CLewey44

Registered User
As for the deeper meanings, it can go several different ways but I'm not too comfortable really giving specifics about them online. That's just me. However, it depends on how deep you want to look at it really. You could dabble in alchemy, chakras, and elements if you wanted among other things. I think going back to the FC MC lct may help tie up any loose ends as well. Good luck researching.
 

coachn

Coach John S. Nagy
Premium Member
A discussion has come up about the meaning behind some of the 5 points of fellowship. I want to research the deeper meanings and see if I can help both sides of the debate at my lodge understand the true meaning. I think both sides have solid merit but both seem to be missing something, what I am not quite sure of yet.

Any ideas on where to start looking would be greatly appreciated.
You can go down that road of mechanical symbolism till you're blue in the face. Should you forget the overall message of safe close intimacy this series of placements is supposed to convey, you miss the entire point of these group's conveyances.
 
Last edited:

Symthrell

Registered User
Such is the problem with looking for answers on this, it really isn't supposed to be written down anywhere. I think that the main point of discussions comes down to the meaning in just one. The problem is how to state the issue in a forum without writing the least character....................

Oh well, that kind of leads me to a dead end...................
 

tldubb

Premium Member
In my jurisdiction we have a school of light usually, that is led by our Worshipful Grand Lecturer and his District Lecturers. Usually after the schedule instructions or lectures they have an open forum on any ritualistic questions. Does your jurisdiction or lodge have anything similar?


Sent from my iPhone using My Freemasonry
 

Bro. Stewart P.M.

Lead Moderator Emeritus
Staff Member
I really don't think we should be discussing the FPOF on a public forum.

I wholeheartedly concur.

The answer to the question is best divulged in the comfort and security of the Lodge and amongst well versed and like minded Brethren...

This is another question which I personally like to defer to my Encyclopedia(s) Of Freemasonry, or other known cited sources of reference materials... I can spend hours, days, weeks in a Masonic library.
 

BullDozer Harrell

Registered User
A discussion has come up about the meaning behind some of the 5 points of fellowship. I want to research the deeper meanings and see if I can help both sides of the debate at my lodge understand the true meaning. I think both sides have solid merit but both seem to be missing something, what I am not quite sure of yet.

Any ideas on where to start looking would be greatly appreciated.
This sounds like it could be a great discussion.

You did say that opinions are varying among Brothers in your lodge about possible meanings of this symbolism within our Rituals.

But honestly i can't understand how much of a debate can be drawn up about it? What makes the topic so open to multiple interpretations? I can't imagine how Brothers could disagree about it???

You're either DOING it right or wrong.

Unfortunately we shouldn't speak too much more about this aspect of Ritual in a public forum.





Sent from my SM-T377P using My Freemasonry mobile app
 

Symthrell

Registered User
I wholeheartedly concur.

The answer to the question is best divulged in the comfort and security of the Lodge and amongst well versed and like minded Brethren...

This is another question which I personally like to defer to my Encyclopedia(s) Of Freemasonry, or other known cited sources of reference materials... I can spend hours, days, weeks in a Masonic library.

I agree about where best to discuss it!! I am merely looking for the names of some good books to reference and do research in to better be able to be a part of that discussion!
 

Bro. Stewart P.M.

Lead Moderator Emeritus
Staff Member
I agree about where best to discuss it!! I am merely looking for the names of some good books to reference and do research in to better be able to be a part of that discussion!

In all seriousness, I’d start at either your local Lodge’s library or at your Grand Lodge’s... There is an abundance of knowledge available regarding many, many aspects of our Fraternity.
 

Bloke

Premium Member
I agree about where best to discuss it!! I am merely looking for the names of some good books to reference and do research in to better be able to be a part of that discussion!
I'd definitely start by asking members of your own lodge about it - especially what is said in related charges. Me, I can't recommend a book because I can't think of one, but would google...
 

hanzosbm

Premium Member
Well, without going into too much depth, I will say that it is one of the oldest aspects of our ritual that we have. It is given almost exactly the same as it is today in the Edinburgh Register House manuscript from 1696, but there really isn't anything in that early version regarding the symbolism. So, we are left to wonder if the symbolism is also that early and simply not given in the catechisms or if it was simply added later to explain it.
 
Top