I'm bothered by the assertion, often repeated by older brethren, that we don't have secrets other than our modes of recognition. This has been said so much that younger masons have begun to take it literally.
I was a bit put off by the degree to which Bro. Hodapp's "Freemasonry for Dummies" revealed some details of the initiation. I have also heard people argue that since there's no restriction mentioned in the GLoT lawbook, then it must be okay to take photos of our tiled ceremonies.
I would assert that anything covered under the Grand Lodge esoteric certificate, which is not in the Monitor, is by definition secret. I'm not sure I'm even happy with listing who played what role in a ceremony in the lodge minutes, except that lodge minutes aren't to be shared with anyone outside the fraternity.
Tom Ball
DI 40-A
I was a bit put off by the degree to which Bro. Hodapp's "Freemasonry for Dummies" revealed some details of the initiation. I have also heard people argue that since there's no restriction mentioned in the GLoT lawbook, then it must be okay to take photos of our tiled ceremonies.
I would assert that anything covered under the Grand Lodge esoteric certificate, which is not in the Monitor, is by definition secret. I'm not sure I'm even happy with listing who played what role in a ceremony in the lodge minutes, except that lodge minutes aren't to be shared with anyone outside the fraternity.
Tom Ball
DI 40-A