Keep us posted on what works out for you. I used to be a programmer (C, Perl, PHP, HTML, SQL, blah blah), but I jumped around IT so much that I've always been a duct tape hacker at best. I've been stuck with my HOA's website for almost a decade because I'm the only one who can code by hand, plus like I say I hack stuff together so its about the worst stuff I can imagine for someone who tries to pick up a book and learn it. I think its pretty normal in volunteer groups to wind up like that, a byzantine website that you are dependent on that one guy to get stuff done, and if he goes afk a week or two right when you need something changed, oh crap.
I'm verrry wary of getting stuck in the same situation with our lodge website, so I'm interested what platform you guys can not just use, but get help from other brethren on content. The idea I have is to be able to have an actual committee, where folks can do news updates, update the calendar, etc. I used dreamweaver for about a day a few years back, but like all wysiwygs, I went back to a simple text editor pretty quick. Just used to it.