Question about rituals in Scotland

Discussion in 'History and Research' started by Roy_, Jan 8, 2021.

  1. Roy_

    Roy_ Registered User

    190
    60
    28
    I'm trying to trace the origins (inspiration) of the ritual that my (irregular) lodge works with. No one less than Jan Snoek has done so before and he says that the oldest version of the ritual is based on "a Scottish ritual". Unfortunately he doesn't specify.
    I have a 2010 print of the rituals of the Grand Lodge of Scotland and a 1986 Emulation. There are significant differences between these two and the oldest version of 'my ritual' is much more similar to Emulation than to that of the GLoS.

    So my questions are:
    - Were the rituals of the GLoS ever closer to Emulation?;
    - If not, are there (regular or irregular) (Grand) lodges in Scotland that use(d) a ritual closer to Emulation?
     
    TheThumbPuppy likes this.
  2. Roy_

    Roy_ Registered User

    190
    60
    28
    I just noticed that on another place he is more specific:
    The ritual for the lodges working in the English language was not created by translating the—atheistic—ritual of George Martin. Instead, probably the Theosophist Annie Besant herself, possibly with the help of some members of the lodge ‘Dharma’ in Adyar, adapted an—explicitly theistic—ritual from the Grand Lodge of Scotland for use by the mixed lodges of LDH.​

    (Women’s Agency and Rituals in Mixed and Female Masonic Orders edited by Alexandra Heidl and Jan Snoek, Brill 2008 page 12).

    As I said, that ritual "probably the Theosophist Annie Besant herself" is much much closer to Emulation than to my version of the ritual of the GLoS. Besant wrote her ritual around 1902, so if Snoek is correct, around that time the GLoS rituals should have been a lot more like Emulation than today. That doesn't really sound likely to me.
     
    TheThumbPuppy likes this.
  3. jermy Bell

    jermy Bell Registered User

    461
    394
    63
    I dont believe you will get any answers here if you and your lodge is irregular. Or our words, clandestine.
     
  4. Roy_

    Roy_ Registered User

    190
    60
    28
    I could have 'forgotten' to mention that. Besides, I don't need specifics of the rituals (I have the ritual book anyway, bought them at the Grand Lodge of Scotland), just the history and the text of that other ritual (Emulation) I have too, so I can't be told any detail that I don't already have of these rituals. I AM curious about the possible development of the GLoS ritual though.
     
    Last edited: Jan 11, 2021

Share My Freemasonry