My Freemasonry | Freemason Information and Discussion Forum

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Search results

  1. MarkR

    Open Books

    I have no idea what you're talking about!
  2. MarkR

    One black ball?

    I don't like the three-cube rule, because if you had two brothers drop cubes for valid reasons but the petitioner approved anyway, you could lose two brothers from the lodge to gain one new one.
  3. MarkR

    Widows Son MC belt bbelt buckle

    Grand Lodges usually exercise control over membership in any organization if membership in that organization requires Masonic membership.
  4. MarkR

    De Facto Hierarchy

    The deal with SRICF is that the colleges have a specifically limited number of members, so if they have no openings, they give no invitations.
  5. MarkR

    One black ball?

    We have a couple of ballot boxes in our lodge (over the years we've gotten the "stuff" from Lodges that we absorbed when they went defunct.) One has white balls and black cubes, but the other has white and black balls. They feel exactly the same.
  6. MarkR

    One black ball?

    In Minnesota, it is considered un-Masonic conduct to reveal how you voted. The Master will also call for a re-vote if there is only one black ball, in order to make certain that it wasn't dropped by accident. A second ballot containing a black ball, or multiple black balls on a first ballot...
  7. MarkR

    initiation next Saturday nmj

    Of course it will depend on the size of your Valley and your class. If you're in a large class, getting to be the exemplar candidate for a degree might only happen once or twice. If it's a weekend reunion, and they're only conferring the "obligatory" degrees, you might not get to do it at all.
  8. MarkR

    One black ball?

    So then it's not a secret ballot. In fact, if the Master can decide whether it's valid or not, it's not even really a ballot, since it must be approved by someone else. What if you know something about the petitioner that you cannot reveal without bringing considerable embarrassment to a...
  9. MarkR

    De Facto Hierarchy

    To be honest, while I do know who in my Blue Lodge is in Scottish Rite with me, I have only a vague idea who is in York Rite. I know that quite a few are, but I don't know who they all are. It doesn't matter at all in Blue Lodge.
  10. MarkR

    Having your light taken

    I'm not a fan of the idea that a Mason can be compelled to "defend" his property or have it taken from him. Taking someone's property by force or threat of force is a crime in pretty much every state, and not something Masons should be doing. However, I'm not a Prince Hall Mason, so it's just...
  11. MarkR

    When visiting a new lodge....

    I don't know about your jurisdiction, but the way I was taught, it should not be used for something as trivial as being broken down.
  12. MarkR

    Born in blood

    If you read Born In Blood, you really need to read Bob Cooper's "The Rosslyn Hoax" as something of a counterpoint.
  13. MarkR

    What do you like/dislike about the AASR?

    Allow me to pick a nit. It's NMJ and SJ. Just Southern Jurisdiction.
  14. MarkR

    What do you like/dislike about the AASR?

    I've read brief descriptions of the NMJ degrees, but don't claim to be real familiar with them. Once I was talking with an NMJ brother, and I commented "the NMJ has pretty much taken Pike out of the Scottish Rite." His response was "we've taken the Scottish Rite out of the Scottish Rite."
  15. MarkR

    Anyone else disappointed by...

    I'm going to go out on a limb here and say that this is not about a "mainstream" AF&AM lodge member trying to visit and being mistaken for PHA. I would be willing to bet that his AF&AM is an irregular Grand Lodge, and the brethren in the Lodge he tried to visit figured that out and showed him...
  16. MarkR

    York Rite/ Scottish Rite

    I've had lunch in their building and have been in the Lodge room, but not while they were meeting, unfortunately.
  17. MarkR

    York Rite/ Scottish Rite

    I'm surprised this went so long without being addressed. While your point is essentially true, there are a number of Lodges, about ten I think, in New Orleans that were originally chartered as Scottish Rite Craft Lodges, and still operate as such with the permission of the Grand Lodge of...
  18. MarkR

    Station and Place Questions

    Same in Minnesota.
  19. MarkR

    Apron opinions?

    That's a matter of opinion, not supported by history. Hand-painted and embroidered custom aprons were the norm in American lodges prior to the industrial revolution. Currently, in no other part of the world is it customary to wear the worn-out plain cloth aprons from the pile by the tyler's...
  20. MarkR

    Station and Place Questions

    In most American Lodges, the square, level and plumb are considered immovable jewels because they always stay in the same location (east, west, south) and the rough ashlar, perfect ashlar, and trestle board are considered moveable jewels because they can be placed anywhere. In England, it's the...
Top