dfreybur
Premium Member
Or to answer you more clearly, if I am unsure of what the genuine secrets are where shall I seek them?
We have lots of meaning. Some are genuine secrets to me. Others are genuine secrets to you. Seek within.
Or to answer you more clearly, if I am unsure of what the genuine secrets are where shall I seek them?
If I am unsure of what the work of the FC is how shall I accomplish........ Oh well, let's just leave that for now and assume that anyone who has heard the ritual understands it. But, even so, I find an intetesting comparison to flying an airplane. One can comprehend all manner of knowledge about takeoffs, controlling in the air, and landing an airplane. However, whether this knowledge can be translated into an actual flight is highly questionable.It is a good question but not difficult for those that accomplish the work of the FC
I Understand your dilemma and can, in some aspects relate. Whether there's 1 meaning or 50, knowing where to start is required; everything else is just fluff. I wish you well on your journey my Brother.If I am unsure of what the work of the FC is how shall I accomplish........ Oh well, let's just leave that for now and assume that anyone who has heard the ritual understands it. But, even so, I find an intetesting comparison to flying an airplane. One can comprehend all manner of knowledge about takeoffs, controlling in the air, and landing an airplane. However, whether this knowledge can be translated into an actual flight is highly questionable.
As the recently elected SD of my Lodge I am studying this material quite intently at this time. If I struck by enlightenment I shall let you know.
But only after they have first accomplished the Work of the Apprentice.JustJames said:It is a good question but not difficult for those that accomplish the work of the FCif I am unsure of what the genuine secrets are where shall I seek them?JustJames said:Who among the brethren pursues the genuine secrets?
Agreed!BTW - The genuine secret IS the training, bringing order to chaos, of the heart and the head, in that order
>therefore the North is a place of darkness.
Except in midsummer when the sun shines 24 hours a day in the far north
So we are agreed that the North is not the place of darkness for most of the year.
And since Freemasonry is universally spread across the surface of the Earth, it must exist in the southern hemisphere, where the North is the place of light.
There must be another meaning.
True. Must be some reason way back in history.Freemasonry is not alone with considering the north as being lesser.
True. Must be some reason way back in history.
"Q. - Why not north also?
A. - In regard we dwell at the north part of the world we burie no dead at the north side of our churches so we cary a Vacancey at the north side of our Lodges.
Q. - Why east and west?
A. - Because churches stands eats and west and porches to the south.
Q. - Why doth churches stand east and west?
A. - In ffour references.
Q. - What are they?
A. - First our first parance was placed Eastward in edin - secondly the East winde dryed up the sea before the children of Israell so was the temple of the Lord to be builded - thirdly these who dwell near the Equenoxall the sun riseth and seteth west on them - fourthly the stare appeared in the East that advertised both the sheep heards and wise men that our saviour was come in the flesh."
- Graham Manuscript excerpt
One brother put in down in my opionion. "Freemasonry is a best of collection of diffrent ideas melted together."
I like these.Q. - Why not north also?
A. - In regard we dwell at the north part of the world we burie no dead at the north side of our churches so we cary a Vacancey at the north side of our Lodges.
Funny enough, if taken litteraly the Graham documents points towards a christian tradition in freemasonry
However, the answer dont make any sense south of the equator
FM Ritual: Classic Greek Philosophy masked in Biblical Characterizations to Purposefully Throw Off the Scent Trail for Zealots.Agreed, though a great many things in Freemasonry point to a Christian / Judaic tradition (which would be what would be expected given time frame and location(s).
FM Ritual: Classic Greek Philosophy masked in Biblical Characterizations to Purposefully Throw Off the Scent Trail for Zealots.
I like this Bro, but I think Freemasonry references more ideas than just Classical Greek Philosophy but also the Enlightenment (lack of Dogma and reference to science) and Reformation (personal relationship with the divine rather than blind obedience to a dogma). Many would want to throw earlier religions in ("Mithraic Philosophy" mentioned above) and cosmologies (Kabbalah) and spiritual traditions (Kabbalah again, but also Catharism).FM Ritual: Classic Greek Philosophy masked in Biblical Characterizations to Purposefully Throw Off the Scent Trail for Zealots.
It is an amalgam